A common man's view of terrorism - Instablogs
A common man's view of terrorism
Vincent Van Ross , New Delhi: Jul 28 2008
Made Popular Jul 28 2008
India :

A common man's view of terrorism

I am not a renowned political commentator. Nor am I an expert on terrorism. Therefore, my views on terrorism take off from a common man’s perspective.

It had become fashionable to say that “Terrorism knows no religion.” I do not know who coined these words. But, a lot of people are parroting this.

When I look at terrorism in India, I see a distinct connection between religion and terrorism. Apart from terrorism from the red brigade which took roots in the eastern India and then spread to other parts of India, most of the terrorist activities that have taken place in India relates to some religion or the other. By refusing to acknowledge this, we are dislodging the corrective measures that need to be taken to remedy this situation.

I am not saying that religion preaches violence. As far as that is concerned, I go with Iqbal’s famous verse which reads: “Majhab Nahin Sikatha Aapas Mein Bair Rakhna…” which means, “religion does not preach hatred…” I sincerely believe that we cannot point our fingers at any religion directly or issue sweeping statements about them.

However, we cannot ignore the fact that all these terrorists belong to some religion or the other. Some of them see certain actions as opposed to their religion and unwittingly fall prey to people who manipulate the situation for their personal gains or to feed some private agenda. It is a very delicate job. But, we must single out these miscreants and pluck them out of their communities and take them to task.

It is important to ensure that our actions are directed at these miscreants and not at the religion itself. There is a vast silent majority of followers in every religion, who do not approve of these activities. So, it would be unfair to target a religion for the misadventures of some misled elements belonging to that community.

Some of the comments of our politicians and analysis that have appeared in the media have gone over my head. I think our politicians, the media and even the security apparatus are keen to establish a pattern in this violence than any thing else.

Some of them have jumped to the conclusion that only Bharatiya Janata Party ruled states are being targeted. Some of them even look at these incidents as security lapses in the BJP ruled states. I am unable to agree with either of these conjectures.

While ‘law and order’ is a state subject under the Indian Constitution, terrorism is a national problem. Hence, the centre and the states need to have frequent intelligence sharing on terrorism and work in tandem with each other to combat this menace.

My common sense tells me that the terrorists and their mentors are trying to destabilize India at different levels. The way these terrorist attacks are taking place one after the other, there seems to be a well planned blue print for these attacks. They seem to be targeting the states and industries that are doing well in our country.

While some of the terrorist attacks may be seen as retaliations against demolition of the Babri Masjid and post-Godhra riots, the terrorist attacks in recent years seem to be telling a different story. True, we have BJP governments in Rajasthan, Karnataka and Gujarat. But, that could be just a coincidence. We also saw terrorist attacks in Hyderabad and elsewhere.

The way I see it, the Bombay blasts were directed at hitting our stock market. The attacks in Jaipur, were targeting the booming tourism industry in Rajasthan. The attacks in Hyderabad and Bangalore were directed at our expanding Information Technology business at these IT hubs. The attack in Gujarat is meant to stunt the impressive development of the state during the past few years. To me, these attacks are directed at crippling our economy which is the best way to destabilize a country.

I cannot forget the fact that the attack on the twin towers of the World Trade Centre in the United States of America was aimed at hitting the USA where it hurt her most—her economy.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
1 Stars
Bharat Singh
New Delhi, India
Your common man’s view of terrorism looks more logical.
1 Stars
Vincent Van Ross
New Delhi, India
I strongly felt this way. That is why I wrote this piece. Thanks for your opinion.
1 Stars
Fariha Jamil
Lahore, Pakistan
Well Vincent, I personally feel terrorism has nothing to do with any religion; its political element rather than religious...

But true, whatever it may be, there should be an end to it. But media in the present has become so strong and especially the influence of the west will never let it come up with the true picture...
1 Stars
Vincent Van Ross
New Delhi, India
Fariha,

I see what you mean. I sincerely wish what you say is true.

Blogging is a new media. It is a free media. We are citizen journalists. So, there is no stopping.
1 Stars
Fariha Jamil
Lahore, Pakistan
True Vincent, dont take me wrong; nobody is stopping anybody :)
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Vincent Van Ross
New Delhi, India
Fariha,

We are friends and fellow bloggers. We belong to the same community. Just relax. There is no misunderstanding.
1 Stars
Fariha Jamil
Lahore, Pakistan
Phew! Thanks Vincent :D
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Vincent Van Ross
New Delhi, India
Fariha,

You are most welcome!
1 Stars
Even though terrorism knows no religion, most terrorist acts are perpetrated by members of a certain religion only. And they cloak their heinous acts under the garb of holy wars.

Unfortunately, their acts only ends up putting their religion to shame. Members of this religion should openly denounce
such terrorists!
1 Stars
Vincent Van Ross
New Delhi, India
Ashish,

You are a hundred percent right.
1 Stars
Fariha Jamil
Lahore, Pakistan
Ashish you could openly say ”Islam” or ”Muslim” as we have become pretty used to to that now :)

Yes all sane and true Muslims denounce it but your thoughts are influenced by what the media says and not the facts dear. Yes there are black sheep in every community and there would be surely some in our community as well, but you cant generalise it. Who killed the innocent Muslims in Iraq, Afghanistan, Syria? America not Muslims and 9/11 propaganda is based upon DOUBTS and not facts. Infact most American themselves believe it to be the act of American themselves. You can get some facts from here. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IBkhMWkzSBg

However, if any Muslims is invloved in any such act, he is not a product of Islam since ISlam says: Killing a single person is killing the entire mankind and saving one person is like saving the entire mankind.
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Vincent Van Ross
New Delhi, India
Ashish/Fariha,

Sorry for intervening.

In India more than one community has been involved in terrorism related activities.

As I said, it is a tough call. It is a tight rope walk. But, we must pluck out the miscreants from the community and not point our fingers at communities as such.

There are good and bad people in every community. It would be a sin to generalise on this issue.
1 Stars
vincent: my point exactly! thanks for putting it in better words :)
1 Stars
Vincent Van Ross
New Delhi, India
Thanks very much Ashish.
1 Stars
Zakir
Calcutta, India
Ashish, you are right that for some of the bad elements from our Religion has shame our Religion. I strongly object to Terrorism. Terrorist are not human, they are Devil in the garb of a Relligion. Islam has never said Kill any humans. These people dont follow their own religion, then how can they understand other religion.These people who does this killing are more political then a religionist.
1 Stars
Vincent Van Ross
New Delhi, India
Zakir,
Ashish may respond to you separately. But, I tend to agree with your submissions.
1 Stars
Zakir

Very well said! Agree with you totally.
1 Stars
’One man’s terrorist is other man’s freedom fighter.’ A cliché but it does make some sense. But nothing can justify such acts (though for those doing it these are justified). At the same time America has been terrorising nations and people all over the world, but of course we won’t call that terrorism.

Digressing a bit, you may enjoy this The Manifesto of The Atheist
1 Stars
Vincent Van Ross
New Delhi, India
Abhishek,
I respect your sentiments. But, I wish I could agree with you. As far as I know, nobody won freedom through terrorism. If you have any examples please do educate me. Please correct me if I am wrong, the only thing that terrorists have done so far is to make life miserable for their own brethren.

I love the American people but that does not mean I love the USA. If you are convinced that America is a terrorist state, you should have the courage to say it.
1 Stars
Thanks for putting down whatever is obvious but ignored. Appeasement and vote-bank politics had brought us to this level. Pseudo secular media and intelligentsia has also helped the cause. Time has come to face the truth but no one would listen!
1 Stars
Vincent Van Ross
New Delhi, India
Jitaditya,

It is our job to keep saying the right things until the world takes note of them and listen to what we say.
1 Stars
ya...i’ve been dong it for a quite some time...but beginning to doubt myself now!
1 Stars
Vincent Van Ross
New Delhi, India
Jitaditya,

Please don’t lose heart. If you do the right thing, you will attract like-minded people along the way and you will inch towards your goal. Rome was not built in one day.
1 Stars
fariha: i happen to have read the koran myself, and i know the idea of ”jehad” is totally misinterpreted by these terrorists for their personal gain. I do not talk about 9/11, but about the terrorist acts that India has been a victim of over the last 50 years. And its not about generalizing, and neither am I blaming the muslim community in totality, so please don’t take my comment personally :)

I believe at some point we need to rise above our individual religions and unite to fight against terrorists. That I do not see happening today, but it should in the future.
1 Stars
Fariha Jamil
Lahore, Pakistan
Ashish Thanks man :)

WEll u know what? The thing is that whenever there is a blast in Pakistan, we say its Indians and whenever there is some in India, Indians say its Pakistan or Muslims! It has been so since 50 years!

I remember my grandmother telling me that they used to live like brothers and sisters with Hindus before partition. Dont you think its political rather than religious thing? The Polititans of both these countries are corrupt beyound our imagination.

I mean will you and i just go and kill someone sitting across the border only because he has a different faith? Thats insane and stupid! And if there is any truth to it, any such people should be punished to death, Hindus or Muslims...
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Vincent Van Ross
New Delhi, India
Ashish and Fariha,

Well spoken my friends. That is the spirit. It really is a political divide. Otherwise, there is brotherhood and love on both sides of the border.
1 Stars
farha,

I believe its politicians, media & at some level, we ourselves are to blame for these invisible walls that we have built up.

I remember spending my childhood having a lot of muslim friends, celebrating eid with as much joy as diwali..using aadabs as much as namastes..those days seem to be lost now.

i wonder if i’ll ever get to see that harmony again...i hope & pray things go back to the way they were..peace and harmony between our religions & communities.
1 Stars
Vincent Van Ross
New Delhi, India
Ashish,
You have a secular frame of mind. That is very important in a world which has its share of fanatics.
1 Stars
Fariha Jamil
Lahore, Pakistan
Ashish/ Vincent we love you guys :)
1 Stars
Vincent Van Ross
New Delhi, India
Fariha,
We love u 2!
1 Stars
Alphonse V
Allahabad, India
You have analysed these attacks from a different point of view. It makes interesting reading.
1 Stars
Vincent Van Ross
New Delhi, India
Thanks very much, Alphonse. It is encouragement from fellow bloggers like you that power my forthcoming articles.
1 Stars
Bobette
New Orleans, United States
Excellent article, thanks for sharing Vincent. I always learn a new viewpoint from you
1 Stars
Vincent Van Ross
New Delhi, India
Bobette,

When you appreciate my article, I back to my page in instablogs and read it once again. Your comments mean so much to me. Thanks once again.
1 Stars
Omana Kutty
New Delhi, India
Vincent,
I have enjoyed your viewpoint and writing style from day one. I walked into this article impressed by the stars and comments it has managed to gather. I thought you had created a controversy! After reading your article, I can say with certainty: there is no controversy in your article. I agree with your views completely.
1 Stars
Vincent Van Ross
New Delhi, India
Omana,
What can I say? Thanks very much for reading my piece and commenting on it.
1 Stars
Asmita
Shimla, India
Great article Vincent... I do feel that anyone taking the terror part is a real big loser... if a person actually has a legitimate point, or a grievance, they can take it to the courts...

The terrorists get a bundle of funds from all over the world so why cant they hire a lawyer and sue the people they think are responsible for offending their religion???

If these Indian Mujahideen actually hate Hindus so much and hate India so much, why don’t they just leave the country and go to Pakistan or an Islamic nation where ”their people” are not oppressed???

I’m not saying that I hate Muslims or somethings but I really do hate anyone who goes out and kills innocent people whatever their cause may be...

Al Quaida blew up the WTC to avenge what exactly??? and what about their fellow men that got killed in the Us retaliation after that???

The fact is that in a liberal society like ours, especially with a secular ruling party, SIMI and the Indian Mujahideen had all the freedom in the world to drag the people who started the Gujarat riots to courts... But since they didnt, it just goes onto show how they actually have no point to make... innocent people died in the riots and innocent people died here too... and no body has proved any points!!!
1 Stars
Vincent Van Ross
New Delhi, India
Asmita,
Thank you so much for finding time to write such an elaborate commentary. I agree with every point you have tried to make. I think you should elaborate your comments and post an article on this. Thanks once again for your time and comments.
1 Stars
Reshmi
Bangalore, India
@ Vincent, your article was an
eye-opener. I agree to whatever you have said, but the point is I feel are we doing anything in this regard except agreeing and disagreeing on some viewpoints? Even I have penned my thoughts on terrorirsm. Our articles are being starred popular, we are getting many comments, but the void remains...
1 Stars
Vincent Van Ross
New Delhi, India
Reshmi,

When I write an article, I do not write it with any great hope that this one article will change the whole world overnight. I fully realise, the reach and limilation of my writing.

I do agree with you when you say that we are doing precious little beyond agreeing and disagreeing with each other’s viewpoint.

I think our mission is to focus on objective journalism with a view to mould public opinion. It takes time but when we have enough people on our side, things start changing. It is a slow process. But, it works eventually.
1 Stars
Reshmi
Bangalore, India
Vincent, first let me say my intention was never to criticize or tell you anything regarding the reach or limitations of your article. It was a very touching article which somewhere struck a chord, that is why I said that we are not doing much except writing and exchanging views, though I am very much aware of the constraints and limitations we have. I felt very frustrated and angry reading about the bomb blast in the hospital in Ahmedabad, but I could not do anything about it. Maybe, that is why when I found your article I gave a vent to my feelings. Sorry if you have got a wrong feedback.
1 Stars
Vincent Van Ross
New Delhi, India
Reshmi,

I am sorry if my response led you to think that I was being criticised or hurt by your feedback. That was never my intention.
I have always treated all my fellow bloggers as good friends and I never feel bad about anything they say–even if they point out mistakes in my writing or tell me that I am wrong. I strongly believe in instablogs’ one liner: ”everyone has a viewpoint.” And, I respect everyone’s viewpoint.
If I have caused you any hurt or made you feel that I took offence on what you said, I apologise to you. If that happened, it was purely because of my poor communication skills.
You are a dear friend, Reshmi. So, please feel free to say whatever you feel like without ever thinking that you would hurt me or offend me. I offer you my best wishes and regards.
1 Stars
Hi Vincent,

I am Richa from SiliconIndia. I am also an avid blogger for a while now and participating actively in Indian blogosphere. I read your blog posting and found them very interesting and informative. We would love to see a copy of your blogs posted here, whenever you are posting it on blogger.com. Here are some of the benefits of posting your blogs here:

We have a strong community of 500,000 Indian professionals
Best blogs of 2008 to be published in a book ”SiliconIndia bLoG PrinT”
Best blog to be printed in SliconIndia & SmartTechie magazines each month
Chance to be featured on homepage everyday


We appreciate your community initiative here and in helping build a more powerful India! Also, if you have any ideas or want to volunteer to help for SiliconIndia, we would be more than excited to get your help. Pls mail me back at richa@siliconindia.com with your suggestions and feedback.

Richa
Blog Editor – SiliconIndia
1 Stars
Vincent Van Ross
New Delhi, India
Richa,
Thanks for your mail. I am busy for a few days. I will get back to you on this later.
Add your Comment