Racial attacks on Indians—Enough is enough - Instablogs
Racial attacks on Indians—Enough is enough
Vincent Van Ross , New Delhi: Jun 24 2009
Made Popular Jun 24 2009
Australia :

Racial attacks on Indians—Enough is enough

With the attack on Mir Kazim Ali Khan in Melbourne on Monday (reported in the Delhi edition of The Hindustan Times on June 24, 2009), the number of attacks in the ongoing series of attacks on Indians in Australia has gone up to 16.

The Australian government can no longer label these attacks as petty crimes. Nor can it claim that there is no racial angle to these attacks.

These attacks prove one of the two things.

One: that these are indeed racial attacks in which case Australian government needs to do more than provide lip service by trying to explain this away as petty crimes and deal with this as such.

Two: that these are common crimes in which case Australia cannot claim to be a safe country no matter what kind of statistics it chooses to throw at us.

The total area of Australia is 7,686,850 sq km. By comparison, the total area of India is less than half of Australia at 3,300,000 sq. km. The population of Australia is estimated at 20,434,176. By comparison, India’s estimated population is about 1,103,371,000 which is more than five times the population of Australia.

The pressure on land and other resources is ten times more in India as compared to Australia. So, the safety and security in Australia cannot be determined by the number of crimes committed. All these figures have to be viewed against the backdrop of the larger picture taking into account all the factors that lead to crime.

The attacks have been too many and too frequent. Strangely, only Indians are being targeted each time except for one. It is too much of a coincidence if it is true. The emerging pattern of crime is alarming.

When a similar attack was carried out on Indians in Canada recently, the Canadian government responded immediately by rounding up all the four miscreants and charging them with racial attacks. A similar response is imperative in Australia as only such an action can restore the confidence of the Indians in Australia.

Considering the fact that a huge chunk of the expatriate students in Australia come from India, it might cut into the Australian economy where education is a big draw from the economy point of view.

In any case, enough is enough. The time for explanations and justifications is over. It is time for the Australian government to act and show to the world that a government which can maintain some semblance of law and order still exists in Australia.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
1 Stars
Hiten
Ranchi, India
Vincent
If these attacks don't stop Indians should stop going to Australia for education or tourism. Let's hurt them where it hurts most in their pocket. Soon they will come to their senses.The capitalist countries understand only this language.
1 Stars
Vincent Van Ross
New Delhi, India
Yes, you are right.
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Hemant
Varanasi, India
It is high time that a few Australian Tourists or hippies be roughed up the same way they have treated the Indian students.Let us see how they react. It is about right time they get a taste of their own medicine.It should be the way that Australian Government is forced to demand security of its citizens in India.
1 Stars
Vincent Van Ross
New Delhi, India
Hemant,
Two wrongs don’t make one right. I think it would be better to channelise our energy towards getting the Australian government to act rather than create a law and order problem here.
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Hemant
Varanasi, India
Getting the Australian government to act! This is the only way to force the Australian government to act firmly against racists.
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Vincent Van Ross
New Delhi, India
I think the best way to hit them is to hit them economically by not going there for education or tourism.
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Nathan
Brisbane, Australia
Indians not coming to Australia for education! will they get quality education at so cheaper rates in India? No.
1 Stars
Vincent Van Ross
New Delhi, India
Nathan, May be not. But, that does not mean that they have to go to a country where they are not safe.
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Anthia
sydney, Australia
Get your facts right mate- there are so many murdered aussies and missing in India you could not give a number -too many. I cannot get the figures on Aussies but I do know the stats for Brits - 58 per year. That is just Brits. No reason for most deaths because Indian authorities conceal the deaths. i speak from experience - it happened to my husband. I reckon that India needs to explain first of all. I would like India to back track in history and explain every unexplained death to a tourist. Even the media will not tell this truth. But that is okay - everything and everyone has to come unstuck eventually - my kids are in pain every day due to f**cked up Indian police and doctors. Tourists are harassed in India from the moment they land from the plane to the time they leave. Indian government needs to explain first.I hope your commonwealth games are a flop too. You don’t need any tourists.
1 Stars
Elias
Bombay, India
It's the weakness of ministry of external affairs and complacent lords called IFS men acting as Indian agents serving only for elite of India.
1 Stars
Vincent Van Ross
New Delhi, India
Yes, we have not put our case across strongly enough.
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Prabhunarayan
Pondicherry, India
Vincent
We can't trust the Australian government. They are racist and they should be replied in their language.
1 Stars
Vincent Van Ross
New Delhi, India
If the Australian government is racist this is an opportunity to cure it.
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Prabhunarayan
Pondicherry, India
We can't change the attitude of Australian government. We can just pressurize them to provide security to Indian students. It is the duty of people of Australia to change such a racial regime.
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Vincent Van Ross
New Delhi, India
It is important to take a closer look at this problem and do everything to sort it out.
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Lad, your should improve your math before buying your math PhD from wherever but Australia:
”The population of Australia is estimated at 20,434,176. By comparison, India’s estimated population is about 1,103,371,000 which is more than five times the population of Australia.”

Indian population is FIFTY times more than Australian population is according to numbers you have provided.
1 Stars
Vincent Van Ross
New Delhi, India
Willy,
You are right. That was a calculation mistake.
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Vincent, Australia is some 49 - 50 times of India’s population and area wise it is more than double! There are too many deserts out there by the way.

Anyways, but I would rather say that it is the Australian government that is the problem and not all Australian citizens. I see some passive support from people but it is limited to a minority.

Anyways, I never heard anything better in Australia than our IITs and IIMs! Let the Australian economy get affected now. Bringing in more Indians and Chinese would have helped them, but they are doing opposite, so let them read themselves to go back to their roots, what were they 100 years back??
1 Stars
The size and population of Australia is irrelevant. No one should be attacked based on their nationality or culture. The attackers are morons and should be dealt with harshly. Do not label all Australians, based on the actions of an idiotic minority.
1 Stars
Vincent Van Ross
New Delhi, India
You are right.
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Steven Gary
melbourne, Australia
Well said Vincent, the government should absolutely crack down on violent crime, australian cities are very violent places, do you know at the sydney mardi gras (a gay/lesbian festival) there were 3 stabbings and countless assualts and brawls, you would have to see the behaviour to believe how people behave worse than insane animals.

The authorities and police seem ineffective and unable to curb our societies’ increasing violence, I know i live in a relatively small township and my mothers friend had his son murdered, and another guy i know got stabbed in the local pub he amazingly survived after being basically gutted by some guy in an amphetamine induced frenzy; a stranger who just attacked him.

So everyone is sick of the young men carrying on like a pathetic bunch of rabies infected chimpanzees, everyone is affected by this violence everyone who i know has had violent experience or knows people who have. The state governments have to get tough on violent crime.

heres a link about mardi gras

http://www.news.com.au/dailytelegraph/story/0,22049,25187674-5001021,00.html
1 Stars
Steven Gary
melbourne, Australia
sorry just to correct that number of stabbings was 5 on the night. Also the article explains racial gangs are a fact of our multicultuaral cities now, especially sydney.the most multicultural city in australia.

So some commentators above think racism is a factor of the majority population singling out minorities; but this simply isnt the case, what we have are minority ethnic gangs eg asian gangs lebanese gangs islander gangs as well as white gangs.

In fact it is because sydney is so overwhelmingly multicultural and racially diverse that ethnic gangs have developed. Anyone who would have visited sydney could not possibly claim that it wasnt a multicultural city or it is a city of white anglo saxon progeny, it is racially as diverse as any modern western city, which makes this violence against Indians hard to understand....ive been trying to understand it myself whats at the bottom of it but there doesnt seem to be clear answers.
1 Stars
Vincent Van Ross
New Delhi, India
Steve,
Thanks very much for your insightful rejoinder
(Global Perspectives)
Add your Comment